We had a small crawfish boil at church yesterday. It was not a big event, so we ended up just boiling the crawfish with conventional cooking methods, ie a stove. Actually, I would call the event a test run since I wouldn't want to do a big event without mastering the process.
For the 7 of us who were eating, I bought 21 pounds for a nice $1.29/pound. It would have been only $.99 a pound, but I would have needed to buy a full 36 pound sack, and I knew that I didn't have enough people to finish that. The price was great though, although after eating them, I am wondering how much larger the crawfish would be from a seafood delivery place that charged $1.85/pound. Even that is a good price since it's $2/pound cheaper than the cheapest restaurant I've found.
So, after dumping the crawfish into the big sink in our church's kitchen, I tossed in some salt. I read before that salt water causes them to purge themselves. I don't know how much of a difference it makes, but I didn't think it would hurt. I thing I did notice is that they were a bit more lively after that!
While we waited for our two big pots to boil on the stove, we prepared the potatoes and corn. We cut some of the larger potatoes into smaller pieces and poked them with a fork. Next time, I'll at most halve the potatoes. They cook too fast and fall apart when they're too small. When the water was close to boiling, we added them to the water. These take longer to cook than the crawfish, so they needed some extra cooking time. I think the timing was right since they were also able to soak in some of spices. In hindsight, I should probably spend more money on these.
Finally, when the water returned to a boil, we tossed in the crawfish. Just like regular shellfish, they cook super fast. We added the crawfish in batches as we grabbed them from the sink, and by the time we had added the last batch, it seemed like the ones already in the pot were already cooked. After letting them boil for 5 minutes, we cut off the heat and let them soak for 20 minutes or so.
After the 20 minutes, I tested one. It was definitely cooked, but it wasn't spicy. I knew that I could let them soak longer, but I didn't want to let them soak any longer since they were already getting soft, and I didn't want to overcook them. I knew I'd be eating mine with some spicy sauce, so I figured the spicyness wasn't an issue. Nobody seemed to mind that they weren't spicy, so I guess it was a nonissue.
For a sauce, I mixed mayonnaise with the crawfish boil spices and lime juice. I saw some people mixing this up at the crawfish restaurant a few weeks ago, and I tried myself when I went back. A little mayonnaise goes a long way, and you have to add lots of lime juice to thin it out. If you don't put enough lime juice and spice, you can taste the mayonnaise, and that's not good. I wonder what I could use as a substitute for the mayonnaise?
So, the crawfish boil wasn't quite the success I was looking for. However, it definitely wasn't a failure, so that's good enough for me. I'll have to do some research on cooking times if I do this again for a larger group. I don't think our pots were optimal for cooking though since they seemed a little too full with the crawfish, corn and potatoes. Oh well, practice makes perfect ...


When I was there, I noticed a few people waiting in line next to a bin where there were some bolillos, which are like the bread you'd get in a po-boy. There were some rolls still in the bin, so I wondered why they were standing in line. In a few minutes, I knew why there were waiting. Out of a chute came a new load of fresh rolls. The first guy in line grabbed probably 2 dozen rolls! Other people grabbed at least 5 each, and I figured I'd take advantage of the fresh rolls too, and I grabbed 4 of them.
